-
50% Of Affluent Investors Said Portfolio Performance Was More Important Than
The Relationship With Their Advisor
-
57% Of Investors Said They Would Like To Get All Of Their Financial Services,
Including Financial Planning, Tax Planning and Insurance, From a Single Firm
BOSTON, July 21, 2003 -- Contrary to what financial advisors may have thought in
the past, affluent investors are currently placing a higher premium on portfolio
performance with respect to their overall advisor relationship, according to a new
study released today by Fidelity Investments.
Wealth & Advice, a nationwide study of 510 affluent investors1 and 320 advisors, analyzed commonalities and
differences in perspective in the advisor-client relationship. It revealed that while
advisors and affluent investors have similar perspectives on many issues, they do
not always think alike when it comes to their relationship-including the often
delicate issue of investment performance.
Key findings from the Fidelity study highlight the information gap between advisors
and affluent investors, and underscore the importance of understanding what high-
net-worth investors expect:
-
Investment Performance Is Important -- Half (50%) of affluent investors said
that portfolio performance is more important than the personal relationship with
their advisor, compared with one-third (31%) of advisors. More than four times as
many advisors than clients (18% versus 4%) said that the personal relationship
was more important.
-
Satisfaction Remains High, But Differences in Perspective Exist - Nine out
of ten (92%) affluent investors report they are satisfied with their primary advisor
relationship, yet only one in five (20%) said they were more satisfied with their
primary advisor relationship today compared with one year ago, while 54% of
advisors believed their clients felt that way. Nearly 30% of affluent investors said
they are more reliant on their primary advisor relationship today versus two years
ago, while 59% of advisors believed their clients were more reliant.
-
Referrals Are Important To Growth -- The majority of affluent investors
(75%) and advisors (88%) agreed that a referral is the preferred method used for
locating an advisor. Affluent investors and advisors disagree on the effectiveness
of social settings, events and seminars. Forty-two percent of advisors said social
settings are effective, compared with 11% of affluent investors..
"While there is extensive data available on the demographics and behaviors of
affluent investors, we thought it would be helpful to understand the dynamics
between advisors and their affluent clients," said Jay Lanigan, president, Fidelity
Registered Investment Advisor Group. "Our study revealed that while advisors and
affluent investors generally enjoy a rewarding relationship, there are divergences in
their attitudes and expectations.
"As competition in the financial services industry intensifies, having a greater
understanding of the needs and desires of the affluent market will be essential to
helping advisors maintain strong and profitable relationships with existing clients,
while acquiring new high-net-worth households," Lanigan said.
Investment Performance
Advisors have underestimated the importance of investment performance to
clients. For example, almost twice as many affluent investors as advisors (63% to
33%) cited improved investment performance as a primary catalyst for transferring
assets, and nearly seven out of 10 affluent investors (69%) said poor investment
returns would make them consider switching to a new primary advisor. Advisors,
on the other hand, were most likely (45%) to say "developing confidence/trust"
was
an important factor influencing client decisions on assets.
Among affluent investors, men place a higher value on investment performance
than women. More than half (56%) of men, compared with 37% of women, rated
performance as more important than the relationship with an advisor. Most female
affluent investors (61%) believe the advisor relationship equal in importance to
investment performance, while only 40% of men felt that way.
The most affluent investors were found to be most concerned with investment
performance. While 84% of ultra-high-net-worth investors (those with $5 million or
more in investable assets) cited performance track record as "extremely
important"
or "very important" to their selection of a primary advisor, about two-thirds (68%) of
investors with less than $5 million in investable assets ranked performance that
highly.
"Performance matters to all clients, and ultra-high-net-worth investors and men in
particular, place the highest value on performance in selecting an advisor and
evaluating the success of the advisor-client relationship," said Lanigan. "This
survey gives useful information on the views that both advisors and their clients
bring to the relationship, and should help advisors forge stronger relationships built
on realistic expectations."
Practice Management
While the study reported that affluent investors are overwhelmingly satisfied with
their primary advisor relationship, it also revealed that these investors have more
than one advisor relationship. In fact, 56% of affluent investors already have two or
more advisors. And while 58% of investors said they would like to get all of their
financial services, including financial planning, tax planning and insurance, from a
single firm, affluent investors with more than one advisor indicated that their top
reason for these multiple relationships rests on their need for access to additional
services, such as concierge services and tax planning.
More than one-quarter of affluent investors (26%) indicated that they want
concierge services, but less than half as many advisors (12%) would be willing to
provide these services. Similarly 26% of advisors admitted clients are asking for
tax-planning services--with affluent men three times as likely to seek those
services than affluent women--yet only 13% of advisors are willing to offer them. In
addition, ultra-high-net-worth investors expressed the strongest desire for
concierge or philanthropic services from their advisor.
"It is evident from our study that clients are looking for services beyond traditional
investment and financial planning," said Lanigan. "This presents advisors with an
opportunity to strengthen their position with existing clients, better pursue new
clients and attract additional assets if they can develop personalized strategies
based on investment services and complement them with a broader range of
services, either by themselves or through a team of outside specialists."
Business Development
While there is a disconnect between what advisors and affluent investors think
about the effectiveness of seminars, social settings and direct solicitation in
developing the advisor-client relationship, there was broad agreement that personal
referrals--by friends and by professionals such as attorneys--are the most
frequently used ways to find an advisor. Seven in 10 affluent investors have
referred a friend, family member or colleague to an advisor, and more than half
(56%) of those who have made a referral did so because they were asked to
provide one. Women are more likely than men (82% to 72%) to be referred to an
advisor, but are less likely to make referrals themselves. According to the study,
the top reason clients made a referral (56%) to their advisor was because they
were asked for one by a friend of colleague.
"Because referrals are a key driver of client acquisition, it's important for advisors
to make sure their existing clients, who are serving as their ambassadors, can
clearly articulate their offering," said Lanigan. "While referrals are a critical
component of business development, advisors should not rely on them to clinch
the deal. Advisors need to understand that affluent investors will consider a variety
of criteria when selecting an advisor, including integrity, objectivity and experience."
About Wealth & Advice
The Wealth & Advice study was conducted online by Harris Interactive for Fidelity
Investments and HNW. Interviewing was conducted between March 6-17, 2003
among 510 affluent investors who have more than $1 million in non-retirement
investable assets and who work with a financial advisor, while interviewing among
320 financial advisors who have a significant proportion of high-net-worth individuals
in their client base was conducted between March 6-24, 2003. Data for the
affluent sample were weighted for age, gender, education, race/ethnicity, and
region to reflect the U.S. affluent population. "Propensity score" weighting was
also used to adjust for respondents' propensity to be online. Data for the advisors
sample was weighted using propensity score weighting. In theory, with probability
samples of these sizes, one could say with 95 percent certainty that the results
for the affluent sample have a statistical precision of +/-4 percentage points of
what they would be if the entire affluent population who have advisors had been
polled with complete accuracy, and the results for the advisors sample have a
statistical precision of +/-6 percentage points of what they would be if the entire
advisor population who have affluent clients had been polled with complete
accuracy. This online sample is not a probability sample.
About Fidelity Registered Investment Advisor Group
Fidelity is the second largest provider of custody and brokerage services to the
registered investment advisor marketplace, with over $73 billion in assets on behalf
of more than 1,800 advisors as of June 30, 2003. Fidelity provides access to a
flexible, open technology environment, extensive practice management resources,
and wealth management investments and services--all backed by the long-term
commitment of a private company. Dedicated relationship professionals work
consultatively to help advisors choose the products and services that are in the
best interests of their clients and make the most sense for their business. For
more information about Fidelity's services for advisors, please visit
http://ria.fidelity.com.
About Fidelity Investments
Fidelity Investments is one of the world's largest providers of financial services,
with custodied assets of $1.5 trillion, including managed assets of $880.4 billion
as of June 30, 2003. Fidelity offers investment management, retirement planning,
brokerage, human resources and benefits outsourcing services to 18 million
individuals and institutions as well as through 5,500 financial intermediaries. The
firm is the largest mutual fund company in the United States, the No. 1 provider of
workplace retirement savings plans, one of the largest mutual fund supermarkets
and a leading online brokerage firm. For more information about Fidelity
Investments, visit
www.fidelity.com.
About HNW
HNW is a provider of wealth marketing solutions for the financial services industry.
Through its Research, Marketing Services and Software divisions, HNW helps
clients understand, attract and retain high-net-worth individuals and families, and
empower the advisors who work with them. HNW clients include 15 of the top 20
U.S. financial services institutions. HNW Research is a trusted source of
innovative research and information about the affluent marketplace and third party
intermediaries. HNW Marketing Services offers strategic planning, branding,
content development, creative services, sales and marketing collateral, advisor
selling systems, web design and usability, integrated marketing and technical
integration. HNW Software offers enterprise and ASP electronic publishing and
content management
platforms tailored to the unique requirements of high-net-worth marketing and
communication programs. For more information about HNW, please visit
www.hnw.com.
1Investors who have more than $1 million in non-
retirement investable assets and who work with a financial advisor.
###
HNW and Harris Interactive are independent companies and are not affiliated with
Fidelity Investments.
Clearing, custody or other brokerage services may be provided by National
Financial Services LLC or Fidelity Brokerage Services, LLC. Members NYSE,
SIPC.
|